Ravioli al sugo, bottiglia di vino bianco e tre calici su un tavolo dell'Enoteca Spontanea in via Maggio a Firenze

Food & Drinks10 min read

First Date — Fall Edition: 5 Places in Florence for a First Date

Five places to take someone you like, or someone who hasn’t yet given you a reason to block them: from a dinner made for sharing to an afternoon cinnamon bun.

by Giacomo Iacobellis

Fall is a particularly interesting season for human relationships. Maybe it’s the shorter days, maybe it’s that melancholy that suddenly makes us more prone to introspection, but when the temperatures drop, the desire to find someone to share something with seems to rise too. A bottle, a dinner, a couch or, in the luckiest cases, a real connection.

After all, a first date is one of the most ruthless social experiments there is: a kind of job interview in which two perfect strangers try to sell themselves as best they can, carefully hiding their neuroses and glossing over their romantic track records. The résumé is on Hinge, the interview happens in person and the selection process often ends in ghosting. Meanwhile, you try to figure out whether the person across the table is a green flag or yet another malessere (Italian slang for the gorgeous, emotionally unavailable type) with a solid personal branding strategy (and a nice motorcycle, or great bangs).

In this delicate phase of romantic selection, the choice of venue can make a difference too. And this is where my point of view comes in: that of someone who works in food and wine journalism and sees food as much more than a side dish to the evening. The places we picked aren’t just spots to make a good impression, but places worth stopping at (also) for what you eat and drink. Because a good first date can start with an interesting dish, a well-chosen glass of wine or the curiosity of discovering somewhere new.

(01)

Santabarbara Desco e Cantina

The date for those who know that sharing is the first step toward intimacy

There are people who order a salad on a first date for fear of looking greedy, and people who just can’t pretend (or hold back) in front of good food. If you belong to the second group, Santabarbara Desco e Cantina is definitely your new comfort zone. Carefully chosen wines by the glass, Tuscan-meets-Asian dishes to put in the middle of the table and a laid-back atmosphere that lets you get to know each other without turning the evening into a job interview with a cover charge. The project is signed by Alessio Ninci and Lorenzo Chirimischi, already behind (literally two doors down) Santabarbara Desco e Cucina, and it’s built on a convivial formula that makes sharing its weapon of seduction.

The opening line is served on a silver platter: “Have you been yet?” The place has just opened, so you can play the novelty card without looking like someone who spent the last three weeks studying the other person’s Instagram. Once you’re seated, let the menu do the work. You order several dishes, taste each other’s, talk about the wine and, if the evening goes well, even find an excuse to pull your chairs closer. In the end, though, there’s one real question, and only one: would you be willing to let them have the last bite?

Where Via Pier Capponi, 34R – Campo di Marte

Green flag a laid-back atmosphere, carefully chosen wines and dishes to share. Great ground for finding out whether you have the same taste, at least at the table.

Red flag the person who says “let’s get a couple of things to share” and then orders only for themselves.

Average spend for two about €50.

(02)

Bitter Bar

The date for those who’ve figured out that cocktails are more reliable than human beings

Soft lighting, a cozy atmosphere and cocktails done right. Bitter Bar is the right place for anyone who’d rather play their cards at a bar counter than sit frozen through a two-hour dinner. An intimate setting, but not too demanding, where the drink can break the ice and the bartender can play unwitting relationship counselor.

The strategy here is simple. Start with a cocktail, talk about the ingredients and how it’s made, and let the conversation find its own rhythm. If you’re feeling particularly brilliant, you can even venture a question about why they chose that drink. Don’t, however, play mixology expert just because you watched a TikTok tutorial on making the perfect gin and tonic at home: the line between charm and mansplaining is thinner than you think. And remember that a well-made cocktail can improve your mood, not necessarily your compatibility. Don’t mistake the pleasure of a good drink for love at first sight.

Where Via di Mezzo, 28/30R – Sant’Ambrogio

Green flag well-crafted cocktails, an intimate atmosphere and strategically forgiving lighting.

Red flag a couple of Mehran’s signatures could lead you to make some terrible decisions (or maybe the best ones of your life).

Average spend for two about €40, depending on how many cocktails you order.

(03)

Enoteca Spontanea

The date for those who want to seem spontaneous but have a precise strategy

A handful of tables, seasonal cooking and a selection of natural wines. Enoteca Spontanea is the kind of place that lets you make a good impression without looking like you’ve organized a diplomatic mission. It’s perfect for people with taste, or at least people who know how to pick a place that has some. You come in for a glass and end up eating something and, without having to plan every single step, the evening can take an interesting turn.

The advantage of natural wines is that they always give you something to talk about. The other advantage of seasonal cooking is that there’s always something to order. The risk, on the other hand, is turning into the character who, on a first date, explains skin-contact maceration, recounts their trip to Burgundy and uses the word “terroir” more often than necessary. A tip from a food writer: let the other person talk too. You’re not at a tasting, and nobody asked you to give a masterclass.

Where Via Maggio, 61R – Oltrarno

Green flag a handful of tables, seasonal cooking and natural wines. The right address for those who appreciate quality without feeling the need to show it off.

Red flag calling a wine you don’t like “interesting” just to impress. Honesty, even over a glass, is still an underrated virtue.

Average spend for two about €30.

(04)

Brac & Co.

The intellectual date for those who want to play mysterious, but with a good cover

Not every date has to start with a cocktail and end with dinner. Sometimes the smartest move is a coffee somewhere interesting, especially when you want to figure out who you’re dealing with without immediately investing three hours and a bottle of wine. Brac & Co., a new space from the founders of Libreria Brac, was born inside an old shoemaker’s shop and brings together an independent bookshop and a café, with literary publishing, fiction, essays and art books.

The pitch is simple and quietly effective: “Want to check out the new Brac?” You leaf through books, comment on covers, grab a coffee and maybe discover something about the other person that isn’t their star sign. Be careful, though, not to turn the bookshop into a casting call for the next Premio Strega, Italy’s top literary prize. You don’t have to prove you’ve read Proust in the original French or pretend to know an Icelandic author just published by a small press. Pick a book that makes you curious and let the conversation do the rest. The real intellectual flex is not having to constantly prove how smart you are.

Where Borgo Ognissanti, 97R – Santa Maria Novella

Green flag books, coffee and a refined setting. A low-risk date, ideal for finding out whether, beyond the attraction, there’s also an exchange of ideas.

Red flag buying a book just to get noticed and then not making it past the first ten pages. A cultural bluff won’t get you far.

Average spend for two about €15–20, for two coffees and something sweet.

(05)

Wild Buns

The date for those hungry for something, but not necessarily a relationship

Who says a first date has to happen in the evening, with a cocktail in hand and an outfit designed to look casual? Wild Buns is proof that an afternoon meetup can turn out to be a winning move too. A Scandinavian-inspired artisan bakery, it puts its bakes front and center: cinnamon buns, cardamom buns and brunch options. Rounding things out are sandwiches made with naturally leavened bread and pastries to go with a cappuccino.

Robert Marrandi’s place is the perfect choice for anyone who doesn’t want to load the first meeting with expectations and would rather see how it goes over something good. No endless dinners, no questions about the ex by the second glass and, above all, no need to invent an excuse to leave after forty minutes. You order, you chat and you watch how the other person tackles the cinnamon bun. Or, raising the difficulty level even further, the salted caramel one.

Where Via Giuseppe Giusti, 2R – Florence

Green flag artisan bakes, sandwiches and a relaxed atmosphere. For those who prefer caramel to grand romantic gestures.

Red flag ordering a cinnamon bun to share, declaring that you’re “not that hungry,” then eating three quarters of it. Food narcissism is real and should be called out.

Average spend for two about €20, depending on what you pick among brunch, sandwiches and drinks.

(06)

Dating Glossary

A little vocabulary so you don’t sound like you just got out of a 2008 relationship with that girl, or guy, you met on Netlog (yes, the long-gone social network).

Hinge: the app where it all begins. Strategic photos, carefully crafted prompts and people who claim to love travel, good food and deep conversations (original, right?).

Rizz: seductive charisma, the ability to attract without having to push. It’s not a sales technique, and above all it can’t be bought with a linen shirt.

Malessere: an irresistible individual, often gorgeous, almost always emotionally unavailable. They come looking for you when you’re not looking for them and vanish the moment you show interest. Usually claims to be “going through a phase.”

Green flag: a positive sign. Knows how to listen, doesn’t check their phone every thirty seconds, picks the wine well and doesn’t talk about their ex all night. Practically a protected species.

Red flag: a warning sign. Says they’re not looking for anything serious, but wants to know who you were with last night. Consistency, a total stranger.

Ghosting: vanishing into thin air after texting you “I had a really great time.” No explanation, no goodbye. Houdini, but with less talent.

Situationship: a no man’s land where you act like a couple, sleep together and maybe even keep a toothbrush at each other’s place, but nobody has the nerve to say the word relationship.

Soft launch: posting a detail of your new fling on social media without showing their face. A hand, two glasses, a knee on the passenger seat. Romantic marketing at zero cost.

Delulu: short for delusional. Convincing yourself that “I’ll text you later” was a promise and not a polite way of saying goodbye. The line between hope and fantasy is very thin.

Breadcrumbing: handing out crumbs of attention to keep someone hooked. A like on your story, a text at eleven at night, a “how’s it going?” after three weeks. It’s not interest, it’s ego maintenance.

The FUL community

You are part of the voice of Florence.

Not just an article you read: FUL is the people who live the city and tell its stories. Pass this story on and stay in the loop.

Follow us on InstagramLink copied

Keep reading

(03)

Fifteen years of covers

The next issue
at your door.

FUL comes out once a season, free around Florence. Don't feel like hunting for it? Subscribe and we'll bring it to you. And if three months feels like a long time, there's the newsletter.